[RR] Mayoi Neko Overrun! Review

“Mayoi Lameness Overrun”

Over the years, we had a quite a few romance drama themed anime masterpieces, ranging from Shuffle, Da Capo, Clannad, Kanon and more newer examples, Hanasaku Iroha and AnoHana. Mayoi Neko Overrun, an anime with enough potential to join in the list of masterpieces, yet, proceed into the wrong path and turned the anime into one of the worst. It seems that in this anime, different directors and production teams are changed weekly through the episodes and that might be one of the main reasons for the show’s downfall. We had all seen anime’s downpour in quality due to staff changes at times, and Mayoi Neko Overrun is a prime example.

The plot revolves around Tsuzuki Takumi, a high school student who is running a confectionery, in the name of “Stray Cats” with his sister-in-law, Otome. The sister-in-law is an extremely good-natured person and is always running around helping people. One day she brings home a runaway girl, Kiriya Nozomi, effectively living with them too. Nozomi’s closed mind gradually opens to them and works as a pâtissière at Stray Cats.

The concept of Mayoi Neko Overrun was surprisingly deep. It is about the feelings of being abandoned and all alone.. or in other words, “stray cats”. I was quite satisfied with the first few episodes, cleverly applying it’s heavy concept, providing atmospheric familial love and romance. Alas, later on, the anime turns into a downhill, turning into another To Love-ru. From then onwards, a lot of random episodes keep flowing in, no more drama, no more tear-jerking, no more touching confessions, no nothing. Now, there’s hot springs, beaches, etc.. There is very little plot development, and even if there is, it doesn’t matches well with the plot pacing, and what’s more, any kind of developments will already be spoiled by randomness and ecchiness.

Most of the characters in the cast has typical personalities in a harem genre show. Takumi, the male lead who everyone loves for some reason, has probably the most random personality ever. Maybe it’s because of the different directors and producers managing the anime. He is at times seen as an innocent guy trying not too hard to be pervy and at times, he is a creepy otaku, joining in the hands of his galge maniac friend, Ieyasu.

The other characters can also be something seen as typical characters we seen like in a thousand harems. We have Fumino, the tsundere girl and Nozomi, who mysteriously acts like a cat and Chise, the wealthy ojousama who can make anything possible with her monies. The characters were actually developed well in the early episodes, as the said characters were “starting” to flesh out pretty well, giving high expectations. But once again, everything starts going downhill when the randomness starts. The series tries to provide some more development at the last few episodes but I would say it’s a bit too late, and besides, any developments at this point will only make the anime even more awkward.

The art, for a 2010 anime, is a bit disappointing as well. The character designs look a bit old school, especially with such big eyes and round face. What’s more, the character models are obviously recycled and reused, as almost every characters are drawn with similar designs. The quality of the visuals differs in each episodes, probably because of the different production teams and directors. At some episodes, the animation looks smooth, while on some, it looks stiff and rigid. Also, on some episodes, the outlines look overwhelmingly thick, while on some, it at least look okay. Though ultimately, there was never a time where the change is good enough to rise the visual quality to at least “above average.” There are also some where the non-plot characters are turned into a blob of white, like this anime here, though the latter is a better show obviously.

The voice acting is quite satisfying, at least, and is probably the only good thing about the anime. The OP and ED songs aren’t anything special though, typical Jpop I would say. The melodies aren’t catchy; you will probably find yourself skipping them through after listening to them a few times. The background music aren’t any attention-grabbing either, and to put matters worse, there are a lot of scenes without background music, creating an awkward atmosphere. The “quiet scenes” without the background music at times work, and at times doesn’t, and it’s definitely the latter for Mayoi Neko Overrun.

The fact that each episodes have a different director, scriptwriters and artists is quite unique although ironically, it might just be the cause of this show’s downfall. In one episode, there is a whole episode about shooting a PV, one whole episode on mecha parodies, and another episode on custom Jenga games with Saki references. The jokes aren’t as good as other shows too but a minority of them are still laughable. Overall, this anime starts out quite good in terms of storytelling but later on, it sorts of became an experiment for various directors. Besides, having so many fillers in such a short 13-episodes anime just doesn’t help.

Rating
Story: E
Character: D
Art: C-
Animation: C+
Sound: D+

Final Score
3.5/10

This review is part of the
Reviews Recollection Project.

Advertisements
This entry was posted by Kai.

10 thoughts on “[RR] Mayoi Neko Overrun! Review

  1. Thanks for reminding me to repost my review ^^

    I will admit that I did slightly like the character designs and artwork (for some odd reason), but I just could not enjoy it either. The various directors as you stated was the biggest trip up and also what I touched upon as well. Would say this is a very sound review to me (albeit maybe one or two things), Good job ^^

    • Ohh so you planning to do this review too ;D

      They at least look decent I guess but not top quality imo ;x Yes Ikr, completely ruined the anime D; And I’m glad it’s too your liking ;D

  2. Man did I hate this series. Hmm, hate might to be much of a strong word but I still disliked this show. It’s really just “an average” harem story.

  3. You summed up the series perfectly. I was really enjoying Mayoi Neko Overrun until around the middle, then I was really upset with how it ended. I still thought Chise was the cutest character ever though, and I enjoyed the mecha and jenga episodes.

    • Hmmmmm indeed~ I think everyone is upset in one way or another D; Hmmm I still like Nozomi best, kuudere is ftw ;D Ooh I like the jenga episode too but the mecha one is horrid.. D;

  4. Needless to say, I have watched three episodes of this show and I didn’t like it at all (I ended up dropping it). I couldn’t take the excessive fanservice and the story was all over the place. I like cat girls, but this was just all over the place mostly because of the director issue, which is the downfall of this series.

    That said, the review pretty much match what I have said when I dropped the show back in 2010.

    • True true, it’s like the story has no definite direction, and even if they want to present one, it’s just too random. This anime ruins the image of cat girls ;p

      I managed to finish it, lol, I’m awesome.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: