All-time Favorite Visual Novels
1. Ef – A fairy tale of the two
Beautiful, exotically beautiful. Ef uses the textbook method of story-telling, it gives us tales and tales of beautiful, heartwarming stories, befitting it’s name of a “fairy tale.” The story itself is divided into two different section, the first tale, and the latter tale, hence a fairy tale of the two. As the story progresses, you will be playing as a different character from another point of view, and it is interesting to see previous main characters appearing out of nowhere. Ultimately, the game’s beauty comes in the form of beautiful story and a beautiful music. It’s definitely a must-try. 2. Fate/Stay Night
Ahh Fate/Stay Night. One of the most revolutionary visual novels of all time. Every visual novel player should have played or should have at least heard of this title. While the anime didn’t do such a fine job in adapting the storyline, the visual novel, as expected of an original material, managed to expose the plot in fine detail. Fate/Stay Night has a very intriguing premise and as more light is shade on the Holy Grail battle, the more epic the visual novel become. 3. G-Senjou no Maou
A visual novel which depicts a battle of wits for the ultimate supremacy. G-Senjou no Maou is probably one of the most mind-blowing visual novel ever made. With tales of epic tactical combat and intriguing plots and characters, G-Senjou no Maou would certainly cater to any kinds of visual novel players far and wide! 4. Deus Machina Demonbane
Based on fiction horror story written by H.P. Lovecraft, Demonbane revolves around the tales of science, alchemy and religion. It feels like Full Metal Alchemist, a more mecha version of that. The best part about this visual novel is the 3D CG scenes, they are even slight animations so even though Demonbane isn’t the newest, there’s no denying that the graphics could hold it’s own against newer ones. Like Fate/Stay Night, intruiging plots are this visual novel’s main weapon as well, as the visual novel gets better as more truth within the mystery began to shape up in the bizarre world of magic, mecha, gods and monsters. 5. Saya no Uta
Visually destructive visual novel, Saya no Uta depicts the pitiable tale of a young man, Fuminori Sakisaka, who involved in a traffic accident, had soon changed his perspective of the world in a completely different manner. The traffic accident that he had, “damaged” his brain permanently, and the way the brain reads the vision transmitted through his eyes.. are ghastly. Everything become guts and intestines and every person turned into some kind of tentacle monsters. Ironically, when one was reading Saya no Uta, chances are they are already expecting this and are playing the visual novel just to check out those scenes. Indeed, it is actually one of the good points about it, it’s definitely not Saya no Uta without the intestines. In a way, it is epic. Psychology thrills, nasty sequences and a tantalizing storytelling a makes up the epic visual novel, Saya no Uta. 6. Sharin no Kuni
Likewise with G-Senjou no Maou, Sharin no Kuni was produced by Akabesoft2. The game depicts on how law and systems can change a country and focuses a lot conspiracies, criminology, political struggles and wits battles, just like G-Senjou no Maou. Sharin no Kuni introduces a really unique government system which aims to rehab certain “criminals.” 7. Utawarerumono
While Utawarerumono has a strong plot, it’s battle game system is quite entertaining as well, which is akin to Final Fantasy Tactics or Ogre Battle. Standing on the boundary between visual novel and an SRPG, Utawarerumono provides an ample amount of plot twists. It at fist, revolves around the tale of one man, Hakuoro, a man without a memory, who was found unconscious in a rural village. A mask was strangely daunted on him and even more mysterious, it can’t be removed no matter how much physical force is used. As Hakuoro live alongside the villagers, he began to experience more and more events which would eventually lead to this true identity. 8. Ever17/Remember11/Never7 -infinity trilogy-
The infinite trilogy of awesomeness by KID. These three visual novels at times feel like separate entities, but they can also be connected too, despite pretty minor. Most players would play Remember11 (or to a lesser extent, Never7) to expand their knowledge on the Ever17 universe; the trilogy is especially good in making the players to review back nostalgically the events of Ever 17. Though truthfully, even if the presence of universal relation is so subtle, one who isn’t even familiar with the KID franchise would be able to enjoy them to the full extent. KID is also known to mix in genres of mystery and sci-fi so fans in that particular genres would love these games. 9. Clannad/Kanon/Air/Little Busters/Rewrite -key pentalogy-
Or basically anything from Key, is bound to be a masterpiece tear-jerker. Key likes to use the formula of slice-of-life + high school + drama = masterpiece. And even after all these years, there’s not once their pattern feels repetitive and they still feels like they are the top of their game. Key had also made certain awesome heroines in the past, Kyon (Clannad), Mai (Kanon), Rin (Little Busters) and so on. Aforementioned, anything made from Key is bound to give you a laugh and a cry. It’s romance and life hardships, portrayed in extreme simplicity 10. Sono Hanabira Seriesand with a teensy weensy bit of magic is what spiced up Key’s top notch visual novels.
Of all the yuri media franchises I had come across, be it anime, manga, novels, the Sono Hanabira series, in my opinion, is one of the best of the best. There are nearly 10 instalments in the series, in some of them, new couples are shown while some continues the cute and fluffy stories of our favorite yuri couples. The atmosphere portrayed in any of the Sono Hanabira instalment is sweet, heartwarming, fluffy and most of all, the girls making love with each other and is always a sight to see. I almost never enjoy H-scenes in visual novels much but I guess Sono Hanabira’s an exception.




http://vndb.org/v53
A masterpiece that nothing since the beginning of erotime and beyond the end of it shall ever trump over.
WTF is that? D:
“Kyon (Clannad)”Wow, Haruhi is really almighty. She can even send people to other vn/anime. :D
Laugh out loud
>_>
Pingback: Kai’s All-time Favorite Visual Novels « Visual Novel Aer
Now this is a list I can agree with (since Ef – A fairy tale of the two is also #1 for me). Haven’t played the other titles yet but will definitely play them soon :D
Hope to hear what do you think of them soon^^
Pingback: Kai’s Answers To Yumeka’s Questions « deluscar
Pingback: Kai’s Answers To Aaeru’s Almost-20-Questions Questionnaire « deluscar
hahha very nice i played almost all except elf the fairy tail of the two, infinity series , saya no uta, and clannad i have to say i have to agree with your choices. But I’m more anxious for the new akabeisoft 3 works XD, but i will try them if i have the time nevertheless
Think you should certainly try it out :D Ef is an astounding VN. For infinity series, I suggest either trying Ever17 since that’s the most epic (imo) out of the series. Saya no Uta is definitely a must too. Akabeisoft3 eh? Probably going to keep pretending ignorance until some sort of translation is out D:
I just read Saya no Uta; thanks to that, I’ve been scarred for life :(
It’s inevitable :D
Yo man, just thought I’d say my opinions on all the visual novels mentioned.
Anyway:
Ef: Epic
F/SN: All time fav
G Senjou no Maou: I want an anime for this one. SO BAD.
Deus Machina Demonblade : Epic
Saya no Uta: Least fav out of all of Gen Urobuchi’s works.
Sharin no Kuni: Same as G s no Maou
Utawaremuno: Epic
Infinity trilogy: EPIC
Key: Epic. Still waiting for Air and Rewrite to be translated though.(And Kotomi’s route to be animated)
Sono Hanabira series: Not my thing.
I question Umineko, Chaos;Head, Steins;Gate,Tsukhime sequels and Narcissu not being on this list though. Mind you though, you have epic taste, but still…
Speaking of Key, I haven’t got the time to play Tomoyo After. And I know I got epic choices :D
About your doubt, that’s because aside from Chaos;Head, I haven’t play all of those. I sound like I played a lot of visual novels but there are actually a lot of good ones I haven’t even try yet. Hopefully I will have the time to try them soon (though I might just watch the anime for Umineko.. who knows)
Thanks for replying. About Umineko, try to stay from the anime; it’s just a complete mess. By the way, I’ve been searching for the Higurashi VN but can’t find it. Where can I find it?
I can’t even remember, lol. I remembered I “suffered” trying to find it since it was the same time during the MU outbreak. But I think eroge download should had by now Think they should had reuploaded them by now.
I agree with all but Demonbane ^ ^I kinda got tired of it close to the end. I really should play Remember11 and Never7 though.
Whose route are you playing? Why not :D Besides, Never7 just got translated recently too.
I don’t have much experience with visual novels. Played Ever17 and a few smaller ones before, but thought I would try out a few of this list. So I started with ef… and I was really amazed. There were a few weak points, but the atmosphere, the pictures, the various problems and esp the end… an outstanding experience.
So I thought of playing another VN of the above list and decided on Clannad, expecting a slightly less tragic story. But I was really disappointed. Part of the afterstory was okay, but the rest was (my opinion) really boring and no comparison to the really intense and exciting ef. The only positive point were a few funny ‘idiot friend’ moments. And I was really shocked about seeing (afterwards) that Clannad got a much better rating on most sites.
The next days I’ll start Fate/Stay night, but I would like to ask if anyone can suggest a VN comparable to ef.
It should be mostly realistic (historic or sci-fi would be fine, but no strange monsters or obvious supernatural beings), not involving ‘nightmarish horror parts’ (like intestines… I want to read late at night and sleep after that), have good graphics and if possible some thought-provoking topics… Ever17 had a lot of these and ef too (esp Chihiro). Clannad surely not.
I would really appreciate some comments and thank you in advance for suggestions what to read. :)
And sorry to everyone who enjoyed Clannad. This is of course only my personal opinion.
I suggest G-Senjou no Maou and Sharin no Kuni; while containing supernatural elements, I equally recommend 999 on the DS and Persona 3/4 on the PS2. Those are also very refreshing visual novels :)
999 is awesome! Best DS game I had ever played :D
For Persona 3 on the PSP perhaps yes, but I’m not sure if you could count Persona 3/4 on the PS2 as a visual novel (wait, I think I just found a good topic to post about), though stories from Persona are usually top notch anyway.
For Ef, a lot of people think one of it’s bad points is it’s linearity and third person perspectives. I still think the storytelling itself is quite amazing though, and the VN’s soundtrack is one of the best I had heard. Well after story is more on the drama part, from what I heard from you, it seems like the former part (the ones more focused on “slice-of-life everyday” was a bit more longer then expected. I only played the very few beginning parts of Clannad myself (wanted to try out Kotomi’s route since it wasn’t adapted yet) but haven’t get to that yet.
Not sure if you would like Fate/Stay Night then, lol. While there are no strange monsters (don’t think servants could count as monsters much.. maybe except for Beserker), it has quite some supernatural elements. And I guess Saya no Uta’s not for you. If Ever 17 stroke you fancy, how about trying the rest of KID series? Remember 11 was awesome too, and while Never 7 imo isn’t as good as the other two, it is still a force to be reckon with on it’s own. Most of the KID series has quite immensely thought-provoking themes as well.
First I like to thank you two for your comments. :)
I did like the linearity of EF, as it was used to develope every character to a very deep level. Because of this the characters seemed very realistic and the reader (me) could understand their behavior. I think if I would have been any of these characters I would have acted exactly in the same way (most of the times). This was certainly a main reason why I liked it that much.
For Clannad this was exactly the opposite. There were too many different characters, too many different paths and it seemed to me that most of the text were greetings, goodbyes and meaningless conversations. Especially in the Kotomi path. If they would have shortened the endless hello’s and goodbye’s and instead developed the drama and the personalities of Kotomi and the protag a bit more this would have been a really good path (in my opinion of course).
Funfact: In EF i hated the H-scenes because they delayed the story, in Clannad i would have wished for a few because the rest was not interesting enough.
I started F/S night and I think it’s not my fav VN, but definitely interesting. Can’t give an exact statement before I finished it, though. After all it’s not that I dislike supernatural elements, but if they are too much they destroy the atmosphere and the story of a ‘normal’ VN like EF or Ever17. As I said above I consider a VN as good if I can empathize with the characters and this is destroyed if there are too much phenomens not explainable by science.
In the meanwhile I gathered information about other VN and on my to-do-list are now (because I think they might be interesting):
G-Senjou no Maou, Sharin no Kuni, Kira☆Kira, Edelweiss Eiden Fantasia, Remember 11, Little Busters, Rewrite (two more chances for Key), Cross†Channel, Grisaia no Kajitsu, Maji de Watashi ni Koishinasai!, Subarashiki Hibi.
Maybe I try 999, Perona 3/4, Utawarerumono or Sono Hanabira Series after this.
If anyone wants to comment on this list or adding something I would of course appreciate it.
And again thanks for your comments and a big thank you for the creation of the list. :)
A lot of the games in your list only had the partial patch released, lol. For visual novels like Subarashiki Hibi, I’m not sure if they even planned to continue the translation, seems like it’s incredibly hard to do so.
I agree with Veruz on Demonbane. I played Al’s route through to the end and felt that things got far too out of hand. Some might have found it epic and enjoyable, but instead I thought it was over the top. I did enjoy most of the game, but it is not one of my favorites.
Unfortunately I can’t comment on your other choices, as I haven’t played them! I’ve got G-senjou no Maou and Clannad ready to go though.
I’m just a beginner as far as visual novels go, but out of the ones i’ve played the ones that stand out to me are:
Kira Kira (with the Curtain Call fandisk) – Loved it all the way through. A certain ending very nearly had me in tears, and i’m not one to cry easily.
Deardrops – Much like Kira Kira, but better! The original songs (not BGM) included in both of these games are amazing, and I really can’t stop listening to them. I see you’ve played this one, and was interested to see that it wasn’t one of your top picks.
Princess Waltz – Not quite as good as the above two, but the story had me riveted from beginning to end despite the first half being noticeably better than the second. The game aspect was interesting and my only complaint is that it wasn’t used enough.
Katawa Shoujo – A free VN that was really very good. The story splits early so each heroine is developed fully, allowing me to become very attached to all of them.
True Remembrance – Another free VN. This one is very short but definitely worth your time.
I think the visual novel was already over-the-top already at the beginning. Seconds into the games and there’s already giant mecha destroying their city, and the protagonist are already facing extreme dangers and before he know it, he’s already piloting a giant mecha of himself. Demonbane doesn’t let up with it’s “wildness” and weirdly enough, I find that nice.
Both of them are incredible games, and especially G-senjou no Maou^^ The plot for it builds up a little slow, but it’s quite awesome as a whole overall.
Yes, indeed I played Deardrops, in fact, I played quite a few which I didn’t review (you can have a look at my vndb list), Kira Kira and Deardrops are great games no doubt, but I’m not sure if they could actually be my “all-time favorite VNs.” I also played Princess Waltz but I don’t have a really good impression about it, I feel the plot is kinda weak and characters don’t even grow on me. The gameplay aspect is certainly interesting but not the best, if you’re looking for visual novel/gameplay hybrids, I recommend ones from Alicesoft like Sengoku Rance or Big Bang Age, or even ones from Eushully like Kamidori. Katawa Shoujo is quite the visual novel despite being free, and indeed, characterizations in Katawa Shoujo is top-notch. Haven’t started on True Remembrance though.
I’ve heard good things about Sengoku Rance, and I definitely intend to try it. I haven’t heard of those other 2, so i’ll have to look them up.
One VN I forgot to mention was Aselia The Eternal, which I thoroughly enjoyed. The interesting thing about it is that, as well as having 8 main heroines with their own endings, you are also given extra main plot scenes on the second and third playthrough. There’s also a special ending to be viewed once you’ve finished the other 8, but given the large portion of the VN taken up by gameplay elements I think it will take me quite a while to get to it XD
I made a review for Kamidori so you can check it out if you want.
I didn’t play that, lol. Not sure if I want to, while visual novels/gameplays are good, they sometimes take up a lot of time, especially if their gameplays are actually something major. It’s why I had been avoiding alicesoft games, they are good, no doubt, but they take up too much time, worse, I’m not really good like these. Tried multiple times but just never get to finish both of it.
I’ve been slowly downloading a lot of your recommended visual novels, but I seem to have hit a snag on Air. Is it safe to assume you read it in Japanese? I can’t find a translation anywhere.
Yes I read it in Japanese, though I haven’t completed it yet. Likewise with Rewrite but that’s obvious since it’s so new. Translation for both is in steady progress though as far as I know.
You should try some like muv luv, hanachirasu, yu-no and hoshizora no memoria.
I finished Hanachirasu ages ago, others are still plan-to-play.